Watch the full episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/vHb5GwZhnSA
Insight decay is the risk Mohan Nair sees wherever people ask a chatbot before they ask themselves. Mohan has worked in artificial intelligence since 1977. He has sold three startups, held three corporate executive roles and taught in the executive programme at Kellogg. His fourth book, Unreachable: How Not to Lose Your Mind in an AI-Obsessed Era, celebrates gen AI and still hands readers a nutrition label for their attention, thinking and memory.
He tells Aidan McCullen that the goal is to stay unreachable by the machine. You get there through innovation with a cause behind it, fuelled by ahas you generate yourself.
What is insight decay?
Mohan places insight alongside eyesight, hindsight and foresight as one of the sights of the mind. Insight draws on a genetic capacity built over hundreds of millions of years. Corporate life now rewards whoever uses the machine fastest, so people let their second brain do the work of the first. Mohan’s theory is that this produces insight decay. He is open that no longitudinal studies exist yet.
Aidan reached for the kakapo to show the danger. The flightless New Zealand parrot learned to freeze when hawks hunted from the sky, and that defence served it for a very long time. Then people arrived with dogs, rats, cats and stoats, and freezing turned the bird into easy prey. By 1995 only 51 kakapo remained. Mohan’s reply was blunt. “When you freeze in place thinking that you’re moving, that’s when you’re dead.”
Creativity and innovation in the age of AI
Mohan separates creativity from innovation, and he admits his friends in the creativity field argue with him about it. Machines will absorb much of the creative work, offering endless combinations of scripts, videos and options. Innovation starts with an insight you generate biologically. You test it against the market and build a product around it, often across eighteen months of what he calls inconvenient learning.
He believes most children can do this. Years of schooling and pressure to finish fast and settle for good enough train it out of us. His book describes an island the waves of AI never reach, and the people who build scaffolding on it for others to climb.
AI-afraid, AI-obsessed or AI-enabled
Mohan finds AI fear among young people understandable and even encouraging, because rejecting a tool still exercises the brain. Fear inside companies worries him more. He points to McKinsey research that ranks fear as the leading reason corporate innovation stalls, and fear of failure and fear for jobs are both running high right now.
AI obsession is the term Mohan coined for the other extreme. The first sign is choosing the convenient over the necessary, like the driver who circles a car park for an hour to save a short walk. The second is settling for good enough and posting output that reads like a fortune cookie. The third is losing your first opinion altogether. Mohan admits his own slide. As a musician he refused drum machines for years because he wanted the mistakes, and now he catches himself nodding along to background thumping he once would have switched off.
Search engines prepared the ground. Betsy Sparrow’s research at Columbia on the Google effect found that people remember where to find information more readily than the information itself. Mohan compares it to the closet everyone keeps and nobody opens.
Three antidotes to insight decay
The first antidote is experimentation. Before you face a challenge, spend five minutes writing your own thoughts on paper. Mohan once asked Claude to retell the first Karate Kid in three paragraphs. Miyagi sent Daniel to an AI karate video course, Daniel earned a certificate, and wax on, wax off disappeared along with the story.
The second antidote is to treat gen AI as a second opinion. Aidan shared a test from Manu Kapur, author of Productive Failure, who asks whether you are using AI for a learning event or a performance event. An expert who compresses two hours of writing into twenty minutes is performing. A student who does the same skips the learning.
The third antidote is to reclaim the aha. Mohan asks readers to write down every insight they catch, including the ones that arrive at 2.30am. He draws on the neuroscience of John Kounios and Mark Beeman, authors of The Eureka Factor. Researchers told him they can record an aha in the brain and still cannot say where it comes from. Mohan takes hope from that.
What the MIT study found
Nataliya Kosmyna and colleagues at the MIT Media Lab split 54 participants into an LLM group, a search engine group and a brain-only group, then recorded their brain activity with EEG while they wrote essays. The LLM writers showed the weakest engagement and the brain-only writers the strongest, with search in between. Mohan focuses on the link between offloading and atrophy. Younger, less experienced users offload more, and he sees a societal penalty building as a result.
Cause over mission
Mohan closed with a story from 1993. Named Mohandas after Mahatma Gandhi, he went to hear Gandhi’s grandson Rajmohan Gandhi speak, with family orders to sit at the front and secure an endorsement for his book on Gandhian leadership. On the stairs he realised the plan contradicted everything he had written. He went to the back for tea and found Rajmohan Gandhi standing beside him. Gandhi read his name tag, smiled and invited him to dinner. Later, when Mohan stumbled through an answer about what he did for the world, Gandhi said, “Mohan, the children need you. Save them, would you?”
A month later Mohan woke at 2.30am with the word cause in his head, and he has written about cause and mission ever since. In his view a cause is so transformative that you forget yourself inside it. “Machines have no causes. They have only missions.”
Find Mohan at 2emerge.com and on LinkedIn. Read the MIT study, Your Brain on ChatGPT, and the original Google effect paper in Science.
About the Guest
Mohan Nair is CEO of Emerge Inc., an Edmund Hillary Fellow and a TEDx speaker based in Portland, Oregon. He has held executive roles in large corporations, including Chief Innovation Officer, founded and exited three startups, and taught in the executive programme at Kellogg School of Management. His books include Essentials of Balanced Scorecard, Strategic Business Transformation and Unreachable: How Not to Lose Your Mind in an AI-Obsessed Era (Fast Company Press, 2026). Find him at 2emerge.com.
About the Host
Aidan McCullen is the 2025 Thinkers50 Innovation Award recipient, keynote speaker on AI, disruption, innovation and change, host of The Innovation Show, and author of Undisruptable: A Mindset of Permanent Reinvention (Wiley). Learn more about Aidan.
This series is brought to you by Kyndryl, who run and reimagine the technology systems that drive advantage for the world’s leading businesses. Discover thought leadership from many Innovation Show guests at the Kyndryl Institute.
Listen or watch now: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube
Frequently asked questions
What is insight decay?
Insight decay is Mohan Nair’s term for the gradual loss of our ability to generate original insight when we rely on generative AI for our first opinion. In his book Unreachable he argues that chasing convenience and accepting good enough output weakens the capacity that produces aha moments and real innovation.
What does it mean to be unreachable by AI?
Being unreachable, in Mohan Nair’s book of the same name, means doing work that AI cannot replicate. He argues this comes from innovation driven by a cause, built on insights a person generates biologically and then tests in the market. Machines, he says, have missions and no causes.
What are the signs of AI obsession?
Mohan Nair names three signs of AI obsession. People choose the convenient over the necessary, settle for good enough output, and lose their first opinion by asking an LLM before they think for themselves. He coined the term to sit alongside AI fear, with AI-enabled as the goal.
How can you use generative AI without losing your thinking?
Mohan Nair recommends three antidotes. Build a habit of experimentation by writing your own thoughts on paper before you open an AI tool. Use generative AI as a second opinion rather than the first. Capture and reclaim your aha moments, including the ones that arrive in the middle of the night.
What did the MIT Your Brain on ChatGPT study find?
Researchers led by Nataliya Kosmyna at the MIT Media Lab recorded EEG brain activity in 54 participants writing essays with an LLM, a search engine or no tools. The LLM group showed the weakest brain engagement and the brain-only group the strongest. The authors describe the effect as cognitive debt.
Who is a keynote speaker on AI and innovation in Ireland?
Aidan McCullen is a Dublin-based keynote speaker on AI, disruption, innovation and change. He is the 2025 Thinkers50 Innovation Award recipient, host of The Innovation Show and author of Undisruptable. He works with organisations across Ireland and internationally on transformation, reinvention and innovation.