Episode Summary: Eric von Hippel – Free User Innovation (Part 2)
Introduction
Host Aidan McCullen welcomes back Eric von Hippel for Part 2 of their discussion on Free User Innovation, supported by Wazoku, a company pioneering Total Innovation by connecting people, ideas, and technology. Aidan highlights the great feedback received from Part 1 and sets the stage for a deeper dive into the division of labor between users and producers in the innovation process.
Key Themes & Discussions
1. Users as the Real Innovators
- Traditionally, innovation is associated with manufacturers, but users actually drive pioneering innovation.
- From skateboards to mountain bikes to heart-lung machines, users create solutions out of necessity, while manufacturers enter the scene later.
- Manufacturers avoid new markets because they require scale and certainty before investing resources.
2. The Heart-Lung Machine Story (User Innovation in Medicine)
- John Haysham Gibbon, a surgeon, saw the urgent need for a heart-lung machine to save children needing heart surgery.
- He approached manufacturers, but they rejected him because there was no proven market.
- Using charitable funding, Gibbon developed the machine himself and successfully used it on a patient.
- Other surgeons saw the proof of concept, replicated it in their own hospitals, and slowly created a market for manufacturers to step in and refine the machine.
- This illustrates user-driven pioneering innovation followed by manufacturer refinement and scaling.
3. The Corporate Rebel Dilemma (Why Organizations Resist Innovation)
- Employees who spot future opportunities (corporate rebels) often face internal resistance.
- Example: Ken Kutaragi, the man behind the PlayStation, initially faced rejection from Sony’s leadership.
- Change only happened when a new executive backed him, allowing the idea to flourish.
The challenge:
- CEOs see corporate rebels as resource drains on an unproven idea.
- Corporate rebels feel frustrated that leadership doesn’t recognize obvious opportunities.
- Balancing both perspectives is crucial for organizational innovation.
4. Kodak and the Digital Camera – A Cautionary Tale
- The first digital camera was invented inside Kodak, but executives rejected it.
- Why? Kodak was built on film—their expertise, business model, and infrastructure all depended on film.
- Employees resisted the shift because it threatened their roles.
- The result? Kodak missed the digital revolution, proving that organizations often resist innovations that threaten their existing business model.
5. Hidden Roadblocks to Innovation (The Reward System Problem)
- Even when innovation is recognized, company structures resist change.
- Example: A head of manufacturing refused to introduce an innovation because his bonus depended on reducing scrap waste—and every new product increased waste.
- Organizations are hardwired to maintain existing incentives, even when they conflict with innovation goals.
6. Users Innovate, Manufacturers Improve (The Division of Labor in Innovation)
- Users innovate for function, manufacturers innovate for refinement and scale.
- Example: Mountain bikes were first created by users modifying existing bicycles.
- Once enough demand existed, manufacturers stepped in and improved features like suspension systems.
- The orthopedic surgeon who added a spring-loaded seat post to absorb shocks is a great example of this process.
7. The Challenge of Recognizing Frontline Innovation (Listening to the Right People)
- Innovations often come from unexpected sources, but organizations fail to listen.
- Example:
- A furniture upholsterer noticed unusual wear on waiting room chairs at a cardiologist’s office.
- This led to the discovery of Type A personality, as anxious patients wore down chairs faster.
- Who notices early warning signs in an organization? Often, it’s not management but cleaners, frontline workers, or maintenance staff.
8. The Hilton Hotel Internet Story (Why Systems Fail to Observe User Needs)
- In the early days of dial-up internet, hotel maintenance staff constantly reattached phone jacks that guests removed to connect their computers.
- Instead of recognizing this as a need for in-room internet, hotels initially resisted change and instead tried to physically block users from unplugging phones.
- This highlights how organizations often fight user behavior instead of adapting to it.
Final Thoughts & Takeaways
- Users drive pioneering innovation, while manufacturers refine and scale it.
- Corporate rebels are essential but face resistance—they must frame ideas in ways that align with company incentives.
- Organizations must actively listen to unexpected voices (maintenance staff, frontline workers) for hidden innovation opportunities.
- Systemic roadblocks (like reward structures) often hinder innovation—even when everyone agrees on the need for change.
Closing Remarks
Aidan thanks Eric von Hippel for an insightful conversation full of real-world examples. Eric reiterates the importance of recognizing and supporting user-driven innovation in all industries.
